About This Venue
Pizzeria Scotty in West Allis serves authentic Chicago-style pan pizza with thick, perfectly baked crusts and generous portions of cheese that have made the style famous.
Located on Oklahoma Avenue in West Allis, this pizza restaurant specializes in the deep-dish, cheese-forward Chicago pan pizza tradition that sets it apart from typical thin-crust pizzerias. Beyond their signature pizzas, Pizzeria Scotty offers a full menu including homemade baked lasagna, their new Scotty Sticks (breadsticks with multiple dipping sauce options), and garlic bread. The restaurant is open Sunday through Thursday from 11 AM to 10 PM and Friday and Saturday until 11 PM, making it a convenient option for casual dining and delivery throughout the Milwaukee area.
The restaurant makes ordering convenient with online ordering, delivery service, catering options, and a rewards program for regular customers. Their "Real Meal Deal" promotion—featuring a 16-inch X-Large pizza with two free orders of garlic bread and a free 2-liter of Pepsi—provides good value for families and groups. Whether you're craving an indulgent Chicago pan pizza or looking for a straightforward Italian-American meal, Pizzeria Scotty delivers the hearty, satisfying style that has made Chicago pizza a beloved classic.