About This Venue
Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli is a West Allis deli and specialty shop dedicated to elevating the classic PB&J sandwich with handcrafted ingredients and creative flavor combinations.
Located on Greenfield Avenue in West Allis, this unique deli celebrates the timeless pairing of peanut butter and jelly by making everything from scratch in small batches. Their kitchen produces fresh nut butters daily—including classic peanut, honey roasted, almond, and cashew varieties—paired with an impressive selection of over 100 handcrafted jams, jellies, and preserves. The deli offers creative sandwich interpretations alongside their signature spreads, making it a destination for both nostalgic comfort food lovers and adventurous foodies seeking gourmet twists on a childhood favorite.
Beyond the deli counter, Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli offers online shopping for their freshly ground nut butters and artisanal jams, allowing customers to build custom gourmet combinations to enjoy at home or gift to others. The business also runs a fundraising program for schools and organizations, providing a quality alternative to typical catalog items. Open Tuesday through Friday for lunch and weekends for brunch, this affordable neighborhood spot welcomes everyone from parents packing school lunches to specialty food enthusiasts who appreciate real ingredients and authentic, handmade goodness.