About This Venue
Mr. Dye's Pies is a Milwaukee-made pie shop located at 3rd Street Market Hall offering fresh, market-inspired sweet and savory pies with a mission to bake treats that taste like home.
Founded by Johnathan Dye, this beloved local bakery has become a Milwaukee staple by crafting pies with passion and tradition in every slice. Beyond their celebrated sweet pies featuring both classic comforts and bold new flavors, Mr. Dye's Pies offers hearty savory pasties, freshly baked breads, and seasonal specials that cater to every craving. Customers can purchase individual slices, halves, or whole pies to take home.
The shop rounds out its offerings with thoughtfully curated complementary products including house-made Irish Sea Moss Gel, Elderberry Syrup, and refreshing beverages designed to pair perfectly with their pies. With a strong community presence boasting thousands of followers across social media, Mr. Dye's Pies has cultivated a loyal following by staying true to their tagline: "Milwaukee-made, market-fresh, dangerously delicious." The bakery welcomes customers to sign up for their newsletter to receive exclusive offers and early access to seasonal and holiday pre-orders.