Fitzy's Cafe is a nostalgic soda fountain concept in Whitefish Bay that honors the legacy of the original Fitzgerald Pharmacy, which opened in 1954 with a full-service soda fountain.
This charming cafe brings back the classic American soda fountain experience with a modern twist, emphasizing locally sourced products and fresh ingredients. Open daily from 8 AM to 8 PM, Fitzy's serves coffee and ice cream all day, with kitchen hours running from 8 AM to 4 PM for lunch items. Whether you're stopping by for an early morning coffee, an after-school treat, or lunch with friends, the cafe offers something for everyone in a welcoming neighborhood setting.
The cafe's seasonally curated menus keep the experience fresh and exciting, drawing inspiration from the golden age of soda fountains while celebrating contemporary tastes and local flavors. It's the perfect spot for a casual visit in the heart of Whitefish Bay, combining nostalgia with quality and community spirit.