About This Venue
Diamond Jim's Steakhouse in Hales Corners is a beloved family-operated supper club where expertly prepared steaks, fresh seafood, and a celebrated Friday fish fry are served in a warm, nostalgic atmosphere that keeps guests coming back.
The restaurant welcomes diners with inviting decor and friendly staff, offering an upscale yet comfortable dining experience perfect for everything from casual meals to special occasions. The menu showcases hand-cut steaks seasoned with Sergio's signature blend, alongside fresh seafood options and comforting American classics, all beginning with a traditional relish tray, warm Italian bread, and choice of fresh salad or homemade daily soup. Don't miss Sue's famous homemade banana cream pie for dessert, and be sure to arrive with an appetite for their signature twice-baked potatoes made fresh daily.
Open Tuesday through Thursday from 4-9 pm and Friday-Saturday from 4-10 pm, Diamond Jim's encourages reservations but welcomes walk-ins year-round. The full bar features happy hour specials Tuesday-Thursday from 4-6 pm, and their private banquet room accommodates up to 55 guests for customized events. Recently voted a Neighborhood Favorite on Nextdoor, this Hales Corners gem continues to earn praise for combining exceptional food with genuine hospitality and a welcoming vibe that makes every visit feel like coming home.